Okay I though 3.5/5 stars was bad but we just set a new record low for an On Ensemble album review. 1.5 stars from In Tune magazine a weekly entertainment tabloid, published each Friday by The Daily News in McKeesport, Pa. According to the rating scale 1.5 stars means “Run for your life”. Ouch. Well at least it was honest and was an actual review as opposed to a descriptive definition and at least we got a strong reaction. In the spirit of “no press is bad press” here is the full review:
The avant-garde musical stylings of On Ensemble, which fuse traditional Japanese drums (taiko) with modern elements of rock, hip-hop and electronica, probably will appeal to many listeners. Sadly, I’m not one of them, as I have no desire to revisit “Ume in the Middle”.
I found this nine-track mostly instrumental collection to be a challenge to get through and, despite my best efforts, couldn’t embrace the music of Masato Baba, Kristofer Bergstrom, Shoji Kameda and Kelvin Underwood.
Songs such as “Waiting” and “After Rain” – with the latter’s use of bamboo flute and bizarre, wordless throat singing – are intriguing, if not enjoyable, and I kind of liked “Butoh-bot Malfunction.” But for the most part, this is a record that is too out there for my taste. Perhaps I’m just not sophisticated enough.